Managing comments on your business social media pages

Chat bubbles for online comments

Say a follower writes under one of your posts that your product cures a health condition. You’ve never claimed that and you can’t back it up, but there it is under your post for everyone to read.

Comments are usually one of the best parts of having a page. They show people are reading, and you get to answer questions in public where other customers can see. But sometimes they cause problems you didn’t create, like a false claim about your product or a go at another person. And in Australia, the business running the page can end up carrying some of the responsibility for what’s posted there.

Yes, it’s on you

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) doesn’t leave much room for doubt. Its guidance on social media promotions says businesses are responsible for comments and posts other people make on their social media pages, where those posts are false or likely to mislead.

That catches a lot of small business owners off guard. They see comments as the customer talking, not the business. Under consumer law though, your page is part of how you promote yourself. So if you leave a comment like that sitting there, or one saying you’re cheaper than every competitor, it can look like you’re agreeing with it. The ACCC expects you to deal with that.

Its guidance spells out what that means in practice. Set clear rules for how other people can post on your page and display them prominently. Block users who break them. Remove or respond to any posts, reviews included, that may be false or misleading. If you respond instead of removing, your reply has to be enough to correct the false impression the original post gave, and the ACCC notes it’s usually safer to just take the comment down.

The ACCC also says businesses should check their pages. It doesn’t put a time limit on that, so it’s up to you to set up something that suits how busy your page is.

The defamation side

Consumer law isn’t the whole story. In 2021 the High Court of Australia decided Fairfax Media Publications v Voller. It was about media companies that ran public Facebook pages and posted news stories about Dylan Voller, and other Facebook users then left comments under those stories that Mr Voller said were defamatory.

By majority, the High Court found the media companies were publishers of those third party comments. Its reasoning was that by creating public pages and posting content, they facilitated, encouraged and assisted the comments being published. The court also knocked back the argument that a publisher has to know about the defamatory content and mean to share it. That’s the bit any business with a public page should take notice of.

It’s worth being clear on what the case didn’t decide, though. It dealt with one part of a defamation claim. It didn’t rule on whether the comments were actually defamatory or whether any defence applied.

Defamation law is made by the states and territories and it changes over time. New South Wales passed changes to its defamation laws for the online world in 2023, and those took effect in July 2024. With the rules differing between states and being reviewed every so often, get legal advice if there’s a particular comment you’re worried about.

Setting up page rules and a routine

Page rules give you a fair reason to hide comments or block people. Keep them short and readable, and pin them to the page or put them in your page information where people will find them. Most cover the same few things:

  • no abusive, threatening or discriminatory comments
  • no claims about health, safety or results that can’t be backed up
  • no spam, scams or links to unrelated sites
  • no personal details of other people
  • comments that break the rules may be hidden or removed, and repeat offenders blocked

Then stick to them, for everyone. If you only remove negative but honest feedback, that causes its own problems. The ACCC’s guidance on reviews makes it plain that misleading customers through online reviews is against the law.

A routine is easier to stick to than good intentions, so decide who on the team checks the page and how often. A busy page might need a look several times a day. A quiet one might be fine with a check each morning over a cuppa.

Have a poke around your page settings before you actually need them. Most platforms let page owners hide, delete or report comments, and plenty let you filter certain words or limit who can comment on a post. Many also let you limit or turn comments off on some posts altogether. That can cut the risk on posts likely to get heated, but it also cuts the engagement that makes social media useful in the first place, so it’s a call to make post by post.

Keep a simple log of what you remove and why, with the date and which rule it broke. It’s a bit of admin, but if a customer or anyone else asks why something came down, you can show you followed your own published rules.

And have a think before you post something that’s likely to stir people up. News items, competitions and posts on touchy topics tend to pull in more comments, so you might limit comments on those or keep a closer eye on them.

When the complaint is fair

Not every negative comment needs to come down. Honest complaints are just part of running a business, and a calm reply in public shows other customers how you treat people. Don’t delete something only because it’s negative. Leave honest feedback up and answer it politely, and save removal for posts that break your rules or are false or misleading.

Thank the person, acknowledge the problem and offer to sort it out by private message or a phone call. Keep it short and polite. Don’t get into an argument in public, even when you’re fairly sure they’ve got it wrong.

How you handle comments affects how well your social channels work overall. Our comparison of email and social media marketing ROI looks at what each one does well, and a page that’s looked after properly tends to be a more useful channel for your business.

Your website matters here too

Social pages send people to your site, and what’s on your site shapes what people say about you. If your content is clear and accurate, followers have less reason to post wrong information, and you’ve got something useful to link to when you reply.

Businesses in regulated fields like law have to be extra careful with claims. Our guide to SEO content for your legal blog covers writing useful content for that kind of audience, and the same care carries over to social posts and replies.

If your website’s fairly new, get the basics sorted first. Our articles on SEO first steps every website needs and SEO trends are a good place to start.

This article is general information only and isn’t legal advice. Consumer and defamation laws differ between states and territories and can change. Please talk to a qualified lawyer about your own situation.